Wine Critic
This site is protected by hCaptcha and the hCaptcha Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.
Charles Heidsieck 'Champagne Charlie' Brut, Champagne 2017
Part of the Collection Crayeres. This wine used to be a vintage product. In recent years, it has become a non-vintage wine, but it is still identified by a specific cellared year.
Charles Heidsieck Champagne Charlie Cellared in 2017 is a multi-vintage Champagne built around approximately 80% mature reserve wines and 20% wine from the 2016 harvest. Blended from 52% Chardonnay and 48% Pinot Noir, it combines deep, pastry-like richness with citrus freshness, chalky tension and an exceptionally refined mousse. The cuvée marks the return of one of Charles Heidsieck’s most storied names, using reserve wines aged on lees for up to 25 years.
Critic tasting note: (2017 vintage)
"The first release of Champagne Charlie since its recreation, the NV Champagne Charlie Cellared in 2017 is based on the 2016 vintage (the youngest vintage remains the “base” of a tirage, even if it doesn’t represent the majority of the blend) and incorporates 75% reserve wines—the principal components being 2009 Oger and 2010 Aÿ and Tauxières. Disgorged in 2023 with a dosage of seven grams per liter, it bursts with aromas of candied lemon, pear, peach and brioche with a hint of praline. On the palate, it is full-bodied, broad-shouldered and textural, with a rich fruit core, lively acidity and a long, enveloping finish. The blend is almost equally divided between Chardonnay and Pinot Noir.
Charles Heidsieck shares its vineyards with Piper-Heidsieck, jointly owning 65 hectares—an area that represents roughly 10% of the group’s requirements. Allocation is determined during tastings, where stylistic intent directs the pre-selection; consequently, certain crus are consistently destined for the same house. Elise Losfelt, who assumed the role of cellar master at Charles Heidsieck in early 2023, was succeeded in July 2025—shortly after my visit—by the newly appointed chef de caves, Émilien Erard.
Viticulture at this address has grown markedly more thoughtful in recent years. Since 2020, herbicides have been entirely eradicated from the estate’s vineyards, where cultivation is now performed mechanically. Although the house does not prescribe specific practices to its growers, it fosters conscientious agronomy by offering premium prices for certified fruit, thereby incentivizing farming that promotes living soils and more balanced vines than they were a decade ago.
The majority of vinification is conducted in stainless steel tanks, typically organized by block—whether by slope or village. Yet, Charles Heidsieck also maintains around 600 oak barrels, and between 10% and 15% of its Brut Réserve, Rosé Réserve and NV Blanc de Blancs spend approximately six months maturing in wood. This, combined with the extensive use of reserve wines, provides a key point of distinction from Piper-Heidsieck. Following long maturation sur lattes, the house style emerges as rich, muscular, and immensely charming, marked by its characteristic toasty patina.
Although the dosage may sound relatively high—typically between eight and 10 grams per liter—it remains well integrated. It is worth noting that for the 2007 Blanc des Millénaires, the liqueur d’expédition was composed of a perpetual reserve component blended with beet sugar, whereas the 2014 release employed a solution of beet sugar and a youthful 2022 Blanc de Blancs, resulting in a fresher and slightly more vibrant style.
Despite the steady rise in Champagne prices in recent years, Charles Heidsieck continues to offer considerable value among the large houses—with the exception of its most prohibitively priced cuvée, Champagne Charlie, itself largely crafted from reserve wines. While earlier releases of Champagne Charlie were nominally vintage-dated, they have always incorporated a significant proportion of reserve wines—most notably the 1985 release, which included a remarkable 60%. The two recent editions of the recreated Champagne Charlie featured in this report—distinguished by the labels "Cellared in 2020" and "Cellared in 2017"—comprise 45% and 75% reserve wines, respectively. Readers should therefore anticipate rather different expressions from one iteration of Champagne Charlie to the next, with these differences being particularly evident when the wines are assessed in their youth. What remains constant, however, is the house’s determination to challenge the prevailing assumption that non-vintage blends are destined solely for early consumption." - Robert Parker The Wine Advocate, Reviewed by: Kristaps Karklins (95/100)
"What a stunning mature champagne! This marries complex toasty aromas with a vitality that makes it easy to enjoy. Enormous concentration and creaminess, but so clean and straight at the super-long, delicately spicy finish that extends out to the horizon. A cuvee of 20% 2016 vintage pinot noir from Ay, with 80% of mature reserve wines, of which a good third were over 10 years of age. Drink or hold." - James Suckling
Technical Details
-
Producer: Charles Heidsieck, Champagne, France
-
Wine: Champagne Charlie Cellared in 2017
-
Appellation: Champagne AOC
-
Vintage: NV — Cellared in 2017
-
Grape varieties: 52% Chardonnay, 48% Pinot Noir
-
Base vintage: 2016
-
Reserve wines: Approximately 80%, with components dating back to 1998
-
Vineyard origins: 20% Pinot Noir from Aÿ, Grand Cru; reserve wines including Oger, Aÿ and Tauxières
-
Vineyard classification: Grand and Premier Cru
-
Bottling and cellaring: 2017
-
Lees ageing: Minimum three years in bottle
-
Documented disgorgement: October 2021
-
Dosage: 7 g/L, Brut
-
Alcohol: 12%
-
Acidity: 6.58 g/L
-
pH: 3.12
-
Bottle size: 750 ml
-
Suggested serving temperature: 8–10°C
The Producer
Charles Heidsieck is known for its extensive reserve-wine programme, which allows the house to build cuvées with unusual depth and continuity. Champagne Charlie was revived as a tribute to the original cuvée, combining the house’s blending tradition with an exceptionally mature reserve component.
The Cellared in 2017 release is the first Champagne Charlie since the cuvée’s recreation. Its identity rests on the interplay between youthful 2016 wine and reserve wines spanning nearly two decades.
Vineyard and Terroir
The 2016 component is Pinot Noir from Aÿ, a Grand Cru village on the Montagne de Reims. The reserve wines draw from Oger, Aÿ and Tauxières, bringing together Chardonnay and Pinot Noir from complementary origins.
The blend is built on Grand and Premier Cru fruit. Its character comes less from a single vintage than from the layering of vineyard origins and lees-aged reserve wines.
The Reserve-Wine Programme
Approximately 80% of the blend is reserve wine, with components dating back to 1998. Some reserve wines were aged on lees for up to 25 years, giving the cuvée its exceptional depth and developed texture.
The 2016 wine provides the fresher frame around this mature foundation. The result is a Champagne whose richness comes from time and blending rather than dosage alone.
Winemaking and Ageing
The blend was assembled and bottled in 2017, then aged on lees in bottle for a minimum of three years. The documented October 2021 disgorgement received a 7 g/L dosage.
The long lees ageing of the reserve wines gives the cuvée its texture and pastry-like complexity. The relatively low alcohol and firm acidity preserve freshness alongside that richness.
Tasting Profile
The nose combines grapefruit and roasted pineapple with toasted and mineral notes. Fresh apricot and vine peach emerge briefly before giving way to persistent pastry aromas.
On the palate, the wine is taut and brisk, with a silky, enveloping texture. Its fine mousse, chalky depth and ripe fruit create a balance of youthful freshness and mature richness, while the finish brings candied citrus and passionfruit.
Aroma and flavour: grapefruit, roasted pineapple, apricot, vine peach, pastry, toasted and mineral notes.
Palate: full-bodied and silky, with taut freshness, fine mousse, chalky depth and a long, persistent finish.
Style: a deep, multi-vintage Champagne, balancing mature reserve-wine complexity with citrus energy and mineral precision.
Drinking Window
The cuvée is described as enjoyable from release, with cellaring potential until approximately 2050. Its combination of mature reserve wines, firm acidity and low dosage gives it the structure to develop further in bottle.
Serve it cool at 8–10°C and allow it time in the glass to open, as the wine’s aromatic layers and texture emerge gradually with aeration.
Food Pairing
Serve at 8–10°C with lobster, crab, scallops and other shellfish. Its richness and citrus precision also make it excellent with roast poultry, mushroom risotto, white asparagus and aged Comté.
For a more contemplative pairing, serve it alongside truffle dishes or aged cheeses, allowing its pastry, nutty and chalky complexity to come forward.
Collector Note
Champagne Charlie Cellared in 2017 is distinguished by its exceptional reserve-wine component, with approximately 80% of the blend aged on lees for up to 25 years.
The cuvée’s identity rests on depth through age rather than vintage purity, combining a 2016 base with reserve wines dating back to 1998. Its balance of richness, freshness and mineral tension makes it a compelling choice for collectors seeking a mature, complex Champagne with long-term development potential.
Recommended serving: open and allow 30–60 minutes in a large white-wine glass before serving at 8–10°C to reveal its full aromatic complexity and mineral depth.